OPINION by Armand Arton, Founder & President, Arton Capital
Many have cast doubts about the future of citizenship by investment programmes in the wake of Russia’s invasion of Ukraine. But increased oversight in Europe signals a promising new era for the industry.
BlackRock Chief Larry Fink made headlines last month when he warned of a monumental shift in global economics, supply chains, currencies and climate change goals in his annual letter to shareholders on 24th March. In summary, he wrote that Russia’s invasion of Ukraine triggered punishing Western sanctions that “put an end to the globalisation we have experienced over the last three decades.”
Justifiably, global powers have isolated Russia from financial markets while many private companies have pulled out of the country or halted unnecessary business relationships. The sanctions have simultaneously spurred fresh scrutiny over another important element of globalisation: Citizenship by Investment programmes (CIP).
As the conflict in Ukraine continues, legislators in Europe question whether such programmes have enabled powerful and wealthy Russians who are supporting the war in Ukraine to evade sanctions via European citizenship.
On 28th March, the European Commission urged member states to end CIP – so-called ‘golden passports’ – citing concerns over Russian and Belarussian nationals and the risks they pose to European society. The disquietude has prompted at least one state, Bulgaria, to terminate its programme. Meanwhile, Cyprus and Malta have committed to halting their programmes in the near future.
For some in the CIP industry, increased, calls for regulation and oversight signal a death knell. For others, like Arton Capital, it’s a positive turning point – one that will lead to an honest, transparent and sustainable future for the industry.
“Policymakers, citizens and investors alike must share a foundation of trust. Increasing oversight makes CIP programmes safer and, ultimately, more sustainable for participating countries and applicants,” says Armand Arton, President and CEO of Arton Capital. “By investing in regulation, governments can eliminate any lingering doubts about who gains access to citizenship and by what means. It also legitimises the process and paves the way for honest, talented people to access a better future for themselves and their families.”
Policymakers, citizens and investors alike must share a foundation of trust. Increasing oversight makes CIP programmes safer and, ultimately, more sustainable for participating countries and applicants.
It’s not the first time Arton has advocated for increased security and transparency around investor applicants. Speaking at a panel on foreign direct investment in 2015, the CEO called for better cooperation between industry leaders and lawmakers, outlining several solutions. For instance, he has suggested enhanced information sharing, such as an international database to track rejected applicants and bad actors, alongside a “common framework for delivering sustainable investor programmes where transparency and security are rudimentary”.
If governments are willing to establish international information-sharing agencies, standardise requirements and enhance due diligence mechanisms, major players in the CIP industry are ready and willing to collaborate. It’s crucial to work together – after all, much could be lost if such initiatives are widely repealed. Countries like St Kitts & Nevis, Dominica, and Antigua & Barbuda have relied heavily on CIP revenues to rebuild after natural disasters and survive the disastrous effects of the pandemic.
“Countries use CIP to diversify their economies and foster independence,” says Arton. “When these programmes fail, it affects everyone – from drastically reduced departmental budgets and lost infrastructure all the way down to small businesses and local communities.”
Countries use CIP to diversify their economies and foster independence.
Rather than run from increased oversight and regulation, Arton says industry players should embrace stricter requirements. “This debate is long overdue and actually opens up the floor for collaboration with more motivated stakeholders,” he says. “It’s a welcome change and the next phase of evolution for the industry.”
The conversation comes at a poignant time. As millions of Ukrainian refugees flee their homes, the value of a second or third passport to safeguard one’s security cannot be underestimated. And while Fink may fear the end of globalisation, Arton believes current crises underscore the need for global relationships with the power to shape the world into a safer, healthier and more equitable place for all.
Armand Arton
Is a visionary entrepreneur, philanthropist and the founder and president of Arton Capital, a global citizenship financial advisory practice with offices around the globe. He is also the curator of the Global Citizen Forum and the architect of The Passport Index, the global reference on passport ranking.